TalentZoo.com logo and The #1 site for Ad, Marketing, & Digital Pros
  Login with Facebook (case sensitive) Forgot?
The #1 site for Ad, Marketing, & Digital Pros
  Fan Page
@talentzoo
@talentzoojobs
Employers
Job Seekers
Salary Monitor Columns Blogs Join Contact Us Help
 
ALL JOBS ADVERTISING JOBS MARKETING JOBS MEDIA JOBS DIGITAL JOBS  
CREATIVE CORNER
Bookmark and Share   Subscribe to the Creative Corner RSS Feed May 4, 2009
Show Runners and the Future of Advertising
 
Job descriptions just don’t cut it anymore in advertising. Perhaps you’re a mid-level ad agency Copywriter. Does Salary.com’s description of your role make sense?
 
“Writes, proofreads, and edits copy brochures/print and other forms of documents. Familiar with a variety of the field's concepts, practices, and procedures. Relies on limited experience and judgment to plan and accomplish goals. Performs a variety of tasks. May report to an executive or a manager. A wide degree of creativity and latitude is expected.”
 
No offense to Salary.com. They’re just doing their job. And so, likely, are the 4As and the government and most HR departments—organizations that really like neatly specified job descriptions.
 
I’m missing a few items from the description above. Like the words “digital” or “interactive.”
 
These are symptoms, from the front lines, of a broken system. The roles inside every ad agency have changed tremendously because of technology in the past very few years. Those of us on the front lines mutated because we had to. But the job descriptions, and thus the system-wide understanding, the process of budgeting and getting work done, have not evolved—especially in the creative departments.
 
I still see a need for Copywriters, Art Directors, Designers and Producers focused primarily on what those roles have always focused on; though fewer in those roles, and with less and less to do. Now there’s a new role emerging—one we’ve been nurturing at Hello Viking—that demands a job description and place within the modern advertising agency.
 
The Show Runner
 
This is a job born of Web 2.0 and social media. I’ve borrowed the title from the entertainment industry, and my inspiration for the description from Los Angeles Times columnist Scott Collins. During the Writer’s Strike in 2007, Collins articulated a position familiar to anyone working in television, called Show Runners. According to Collins, they are:
 
“... ‘hyphenates,’ a curious hybrid of starry-eyed artists and tough-as-nails operational managers. They're not just writers; they're not just producers. They… develop story lines, write scripts, cast actors, mind budgets and run interference with studio and network bosses. It's one of the most unusual and demanding, right-brain/left-brain job descriptions in the entertainment world.”
 
Doesn’t this sound somewhat familiar? Let’s consider the workload for a Show Runner working in marketing and advertising right now:
 
They can write
The most obvious skill. Half of advertising is words, especially in the digital space. The best writers are still the best writers, regardless of where their words come to life.
 
They can write code
Another way to put this is, they’re not afraid of code. These people might not be fulltime developers, but they’re willing and able to parse some HTML, a little CSS and even Flash. They’ve demonstrated this ability, too, by creating and augmenting their own digital profiles.
 
They’ve got PR skills
Show Runners intuitively understand the communal and conversational aspects of social media. They understand the quid pro quo and have acted accordingly. They’ve created relationships online; they comment on blogs; they promote others as much as themselves. You can trust them in front of the mic or a camera or during a Twitter storm.
 
They can research, measure and analyze
In other words, they’re strategic thinkers. And detectives. In the larger agencies, you might have an entire department dedicated to these tasks. But Show Runners can work alone, if need be, to get the goods. For example, a Show Runner can parse an AdWords account and make appropriate, immediate decisions about keywords and campaigns.
 
They’re naturally integrated
You know the type—Collins calls them “hyphenates.” They can deliver great work across any medium, in any medium. They not afraid to design a button for a website and deliver the layered PSD for development. Or edit a movie. They’re comfortable in the recording studio and on the film set.
 
They’re entrepreneurial
You don’t have to ask a Show Runner to get started. In fact, the best are working for you and developing their own online content, their own web and mobile apps, on the side.
 
The Show Runner is listening, analyzing, suggesting appropriate action and responding swiftly, because the nature of our instantaneous digital culture requires it. They are, in some respects, an advertising agency of one. Tim Brown, CEO of IDEO, might describe them as T-Shape People, “They have a principal skill that describes the vertical leg of the T… But they are so empathetic that they can branch out into other skills… and do them as well.” In the modern cycle of marketing and communications, Show Runners literally keep your brand’s show running.
 
When a client asks me how a complex, integrated social media campaign will get done, and who will do the work, I describe the role above. In fact, I suspect Hello Viking will employ mostly Show Runners in the near future, and ask them to moonlight in traditional ad mediums—as the work of marketing jumps from finite, long-developing campaigns into nimble, infinite, always-on conversations.

Bookmark and Share   Subscribe to the Creative Corner RSS Feed

Comments
Add Your Comments
Tim Brunelle (Minneapolis) on 07 May 2009 at 3:10 pm

Interesting thread emerging here.

I agree with Sarah, NY Ad Guy and Jerry Matthews on the difficulty of displaying hybrid/hyphenate talent. The ad industry suffers for not readily embracing new roles—just look at Designers with ad agency structures. And since agencies haven't accounted for the roles, they won't pay realistic salaries for the work being done. (Totally agree, NY Ad Guy.)

x92GTIx - I'd say you're stuck in the same boat. The solution seems to be to use the tools out there to identify all you *can* do. Try using http://extendr.com to display your various talents within one URL.

CompleteWriter - Totally agree about the craft of writing. I've got a well worn copy of Stephen King's "A Memoir to the Craft" on my desk. So I hear you. But I suggest broadening your definition of writing. Digitalent makes some good points. Do you consider haiku an acceptable form of "writing?" If so, why not 140-character limits? The digital space merely ascribes more rules than generally apply to print ad writing. But there's still plenty of great writing out there.

Thanks for all the inspired commentary.

Tim

Harry Pujols (New York, NY) on 06 May 2009 at 3:06 pm

I always had trouble describing what I do to the agency folks. I guess this article pretty much sums it up.

Digitalent on 05 May 2009 at 8:05 pm

CompleteWriter,

I’ll hazard a guess that you’ve never really worked at a digital agency – which kinda makes you an IncompleteWriter. The Catch-22 with writing for digital is the requirements of the space. That is, you can’t just be focused on generating breakthrough content (which I suspect you would define through the lens of a traditional advertising copywriter). You also must be thoroughly versed in the functionality components. And heaven forbid anyone is interested in search optimization. Take a close look at any website. Someone has to write every piece of copy you “experience” – right down to the 404 error pages. The truth is, the gifts of creative content creation and the gifts of functionality details rarely reside in the same person. Yet that’s what’s expected at most major digital agencies. It’s also why there is so little decent writing to be seen on the Web. And so many typos and bad grammar.

x92GTIx (Toledo) on 05 May 2009 at 3:20 pm

Where does all of this leave us (print) production folks? How do we become a part of this hybridization making us more marketable?

CompleteWriter (San Diego) on 05 May 2009 at 2:12 pm

The fact remains...writing is a craft that takes skill, nuance, patience and artistry. So much of what is passed off as "content" is nothing more than crap. To write well requires that one read voluminously. Get your face away from the screen and pick up a book. Put down that idiotic Twitter nonsense and read a respected newspaper. Who the hell cares what somebody else "is doing right now"?

jerry matthews (huntington beach, ca) on 05 May 2009 at 1:13 pm

you've made some great points here. as an experienced copywriter who is currently looking for work (freelance or full-time), i've been trying to overcome the very obstacles you point out. my skill set goes beyond "copywriter." i blog, have done my own art direction (adequately, but still know when to turn to the real art pros), even built my own portfolio web site. i recognize that the more i know about social media, SEO, html coding, and even basic program knowledge, the more valuable i am. the difficulty is getting other people to see it, too.

NY Ad Guy (New York) on 05 May 2009 at 11:30 am

I'd be happy to take the job you describe in your description, along with the $250K annual salary that it would need to command, which would adequately compensate me for the skill set you seem to require and maintaining and updating it as necessary. What amuses me is that employers want all of this, and they seem to think it should cost them under $100K per year per employee. Get real!

sarah (http://blogs.nppa.org/region1/) on 05 May 2009 at 11:21 am

Dilemma for job searcher, me, is to find a descriptive title that embraces that multi-discipline hybrid talent. I've morphed from Picture Editor (no video, multimedia, analytic reference) to New Media Visual Editor (no production reference) to New Media Visual Professional. None are industry standards.

Recently saw someone using "creative and experienced senior visual industry professional" as a title.

I agree with digitalent - the article describes what many folks do on daily basis at work. Broad skills and platform-neutral. But when applying for these jobs, the software requirements read like a very focused web producer position.

Tim Brunelle (Minneapolis) on 05 May 2009 at 1:55 am

Exactly, Digitalent! Part of the struggle with descriptions is who writes them. Not to slam HR, but if they end up writing it, they'll focus on things they were taught--and things they focus on in their own description, versus what the role actual is. Also, most job descriptions, even in digital shops, are outdated--from a time when we all focused on mastery of specific software, and the notion of hiring a writer was extreme. The "Show Runner" is only one example of a new role the befits the times. I'm sure we'll see more hybrid/hyphenate examples appear, hopefully with useful descriptions.

Tim

Digitalent on 04 May 2009 at 8:30 pm

This is an interesting perspective. So why do all the job listings for digital roles sound quite the opposite, with employers defining people right down to the exact programs and software expertise? For that matter, why do so many digital shops rarely have legitimate writers on staff? And when I say writers, I don't mean traditional advertising copywriters, but rather, people capable of creating meaningful and compelling content. Perhaps we should just eliminate job descriptions altogether.

Display Name: 
Location: 
E-Mail Address: 
Comments: 
 
Enter numbers Why? 

As a writer, creative director and drummer, Tim started in advertising in 1993 after receiving a B.A. in Jazz from the University of Cincinnati. Since then, he's worked with TBWA/Chiat Day, Heater/Easdon, McKinney & Silver, Arnold Worldwide, OgilvyOne, Mullen and Carmichael Lynch. Tim now works for his own entity, Hello Viking.

Tim has provided strategic and creative leadership to A.G. Edwards, Anheuser-Busch, Brown Forman, Goodyear, Harley-Davidson, Porsche, PricewaterhouseCoopers, and Volkswagen.



RELATED ARTICLES  
The Digital Jump

The Short of the Long

Finding Inspiration

Integrated Marketing. For Guns and Roses, “it’s so easy.” For Ad Agencies, Not So Much.

Advertise on TalentZoo.com
Return to Top