|
The rush of brands wanting to add social media components to their advertising campaigns is quite sickening. Have we really not evolved beyond the methods used in TV, print, and radio? If we are kind, we can say companies are getting involved in the conversations taking place about their brands online, and some are trying to guide those conversations in a positive light. Unfortunately, however, social media is largely being used by brands as just another communication channel to push a message, drive awareness, and promote products and services. Brands and the agencies they hire to tweet for them are missing the point.
There are more productive ways of using the unique capabilities that social media provides. For example, what can a nightclub teach us about using social media? Recently, Nic Adler, owner of The Roxy Theatre in West Hollywood, was interviewed on NPR. He explained how in past years The Roxy, like many nightclubs on the strip, had fallen on hard times. He points to the club's effective use of social media as one of the main reasons for their revival. Unlike other venues, The Roxy encourages fans to take photos, videotape, and share live footage from the shows. They have taken deliberate steps to provide a platform for fan created content to be shared, such as a channel on YouTube.
Now, let’s look at a great company not using social media to the fullest. General Mills’ new brand extension for Wheaties Fuel. It has a Facebook page and a Twitter account, @Wheaties_Fuel. Fuel’s Twitter account is mention after mention of other users’ accounts with, “Give Fuel a try and let us know what you think.” How unimaginative! To give them a little credit, their use of featured athletes allows them to talk about recent sporting events, but again, this regional content only makes the message somewhat more relevant to some of the audience. It’s still pushing a message like traditional media.
Another General Mills brand doing slightly better in social media, Betty Crocker, provides recipes that of course include their own ingredients. What can a telecommunications giant teach a CPG company? BT’s use to Twitter through @BTCare provides customer service by answering and solving specific customer concerns. One may ask what does this have to do with baking ingredients. Betty Crocker could do more than suggest their own recipes and retweet favorable customer content. What if Betty Crocker leveraged all their internal food scientists and nutritionists to answer specific customer questions or help customers create their own unique recipes?
Beyond providing a platform for others to share and solving customer problems, there is another step up on the social media ladder. Social media allows the fusion between marketing and operations. If customers are passionate enough to share their opinions with the entire world, shouldn’t we be listening? Real time customer feedback found through social media can provide a powerful opportunity to improve products and services. By having the proper tools to listen and empowering the right individuals within the organization to make changes can turn a brand’s biggest detractors into converts. Social Media should not be reduced to a part of a campaign. It can be a platform, a service, and an opportunity to improve.
|
|
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
| Rebecca Dias (Phoenix, AZ) |
on 03 Aug 2010 at 7:55 pm |
|
| Great article—Social media isn’t just about brands becoming more ‘personal,’ it’s about the ‘branding’ of individuals through the creation of online profiles and identities. This mutual ‘marketing’—of the company to the individual (traditional) and the individual to an online audience, creates a new forum for corporate-consumer dialogue in which the consumer voice acquires equal, if not greater authority, in defining product success than the voice of the brand itself. The TV/ radio strategy can’t succeed when formerly passive listeners become active participants in brand creation. Which means that capitalizing through social media is about facilitating consumer conversation, rather than pushing brand symbols. |
|
| sheila (nottingham) |
on 03 Aug 2010 at 4:40 pm |
|
| Are you getting dizzy on your virtual horse? |
|
| Jan McKay (San Clemente, CA) |
on 03 Aug 2010 at 4:01 pm |
|
Hi Ed,
As a consultant for nonprofit destinations (museums, historic sites, performing arts etc.) I find that our professionals are very eager to use every available tactic. Some are doing a whole lot more with social media than pushing through messages of their own, but we have a long way to go. We all need to keep learning and so thank you for putting the spotlight where it needs to be.
Jan www.janmckayandassociates.com |
|
| Sean Duffy (Boston, MA / Malmö, Sweden ) |
on 03 Aug 2010 at 12:24 pm |
|
Ed,
Bravo! You have framed the problem very well. I agree that using social media for push purposes is a bad idea all around and that there is a lot of it going on.
I also agree with Kelly's comment about agencies contributing to the problem. But as an agency that is trying to educate its clients, I can tell you it is thankless work since most clients make for reluctant pupils. As you mention, it was the same in the 90's when the internet appeared on the scene.
What makes it all worth it is when you find an individual with the right combination of intellect and self-confidence to learn a new approach and master it. Those are the clients that my agency turns itself inside-out for. Hope to see their numbers increase in the near future.
Thanks for a great post,
Sean
@brandranter
www.theduffyagency.com |
|
| Gilda Horgan (Walpole, MA) |
on 03 Aug 2010 at 11:51 am |
|
Very true. Social media is just that - a way to be social. Companies who do not want to participate in or initiate conversation are going to lose followers. Your customers want to be heard and this is the perfect venue with which to listen.
http://web.mac.com/g.horgan.portfolio/iWeb/Site/Welcome.html |
|
| Doris A Phillips (Minneapolis, MN) |
on 28 Jul 2010 at 7:33 pm |
|
Ed, I agree with you and Kelly. Marketers see this an an opportunity for pushing messages--how limiting!
I listened to the NPR program about the Roxy, too and was surprised that Nic Adler hadn't thought of using twitter etc. before since it seemed to me (as a market research I probably think a bit differently than others, though) a perfect fit with the oh so social nightclub scene. Glad that he had smart marketers to guide him in the right direction. I have 20+ years of experience and am looking forward to using these new sources of info as a way to get a more accurate pic of customers and what they think/how they use/what they need with the next version of products. My recommendations can become stronger with more of this type of info. Companies with the technologies to make twitter messages easy to analyze will become my best friends in the future. Keep on writing this kind of article! |
|
| Michel J. Gagnon (Montreal, Canada) |
on 28 Jul 2010 at 2:58 pm |
|
Hi Ed,
I'm also tired of seeing traditional media use the exact same old tactics but through new media.
A lot of journalists/columnists do exactly that with their "blogs." They write their column on a blog and feel like they've master the world of 2.0. That's the same condescending attitude of the past.
I agree with you that there's a need for more interaction and creativity. But as with any other new technological development, there's a learning period. I'm confident that we'll get there.
Thanks
Michel
Blog: http://www.waliqfactory.com |
|
| Kelly Ross Kerr (OFallon, MO) |
on 28 Jul 2010 at 10:39 am |
|
Ed,
Well said! I agree 100% that a lot of companies are missing tremendous opportunities in the use of social media. I also believe that as the medium grows, this will work itself out, much like the old days when companies first started building web sites and had to go through the growing pains of getting an online presence. But how long that will take, who knows.
What bothers me a little bit are the agencies or contractors that are guiding the companies that only push marketing messages. These are the guys that should be helping educate their clients on the possibilities of building relationships with their customers, not just taking their money to "fire and forget" twitter messages.
Thanks again for a great article.
Kelly Ross Kerr
kkerr@producedbyabear.com
LinkedIN: http://www.linkedin.com/in/kellyrosskerr
Web: http://www.exitmediaservices.com
Blog: http://producedbyabear.blogspot.com
Web: http://www.producedbyabear.com |
|
|
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
About the Author Ed Reilly |
|
 |
 |
 |
Ed Reilly is a graduate of VCU Brandcenter and has worked as a researcher and strategist for advertising agencies and most recently, a product design firm. His breadth of experience includes immersion into NASCAR fan culture and empathizing with the hopes and fears of patients fighting severe illnesses. As his career has progressed, he has learned to value consumer insights without neglecting the need to create compelling product experiences. Connect with him on LinkedIn.

 |
Newest Jobs |  |
Copywriter Littlefield Tulsa, Oklahoma |
Account Manager - Atlanta Totem Atlanta, Georgia |
Associate Account Manager - Atlanta Totem Atlanta, Georgia |
Account Coordinator Totem Atlanta, Georgia |
Senior Art Director / Designer Hats Off Creative Charlotte, North Carolina |
Copywriter / Senior Copywriter – MANAGED... Medaccess San Diego, California |
Sr. Art Director Brunner Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania |
Copywriter Brunner Atlanta, Georgia |
Senior Interactive Designer/Art Director LM&O Advertising Arlington, Virginia |
Senior Media Planner/Buyer Eric Mower and Associates Buffalo, New York |
Administravie Assistant Landor Associates Cincinnati, Ohio |
Art Director / Graphic Designer (soon to b... the bounce agency Greenville, South Carolina |
Marketing Coordinator ProPhase Labs Doylestown, Pennsylvania |
Graphic/Web Designer Intern CHARGE Anywhere South Plainfield, New Jersey |
E-Services Marketing Specialist Teachers Credit Union South Bend, Indiana |
Advertising Jobs
Marketing Jobs
Media Jobs
Digital Jobs |
|
|